Your VEFA developer refuses to clear your reservations: what the law says
Reservations recorded in the handover report constitute a contractual obligation of performance (Article 1231-1 of the French Civil Code). If the developer refuses to clear them beyond a reasonable period (generally 6 months), you can demand forced performance, have the work carried out by a third party at the developer’s expense, or take legal action for damages. The 5% VEFA balance stays held by the bank until reservations are fully cleared: this is your guarantee.
Why you need to act fast: what’s really at stake
Letting the matter drag on exposes you to several risks:
- Frozen funds: your balance remains unavailable; the bank will only release it once presented with the developer’s signed reservation-clearance statement.
- Worsening defects: 6 months is the critical threshold. After that, cracks widen, damp spreads, and traces of unfinished work get worse. Evidence documented at month 6 is worth 10 times more than at month 12.
- Time limitation: although the 10-year structural warranty (Article 1792 of the Civil Code) runs for 10 years, your right to enforce reservations erodes if you don’t actively assert it within 6 to 12 months of handover.
- Repeated expert fees: every month of delay can justify another site visit. A single, comprehensive costed report that forces the developer to act is far more effective.
Scenario 1: Formal notice and forced performance (Art. 1231-1 Civil Code)
The first legal step is a formal notice sent by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt to the developer. This letter must:
- Reference the handover report and the outstanding reservations (precise list).
- Set a deadline (21 days minimum, often 30 days in practice).
- Warn that work will be carried out by a third party at the developer’s expense if they refuse to act.
If the developer ignores this formal notice, you can have the work carried out by a third party (general contractor, specialist tradespeople) at the developer’s expense. The building expert then produces a detailed, contractual cost estimate: this is the document that legally justifies the ordered works.
Scenario 2: Third-party execution and cost recovery
You launch the works without waiting for the developer:
- Prior expert assessment (Cassini): joint inspection of the reservations, dated photos, itemised quote.
- Tender to 2-3 companies: keep all the quotes.
- Execution: pay for the work, keep the invoices and completion certificates.
- Court summons (Grasse for Antibes, Nice or Toulon depending on the developer’s registered office): claim full reimbursement of the works cost plus interest and legal fees (Art. 1231-1, Art. 1344-1 Civil Code).
Important: this strategy only works if the Cassini assessment costs each reservation unambiguously. A court will never award you more than what you have proven. Hence the importance of a detailed, dated cost estimate.
Scenario 3: Legal action and court order (Art. 1231-1, 1792 Civil Code)
You summon the developer before the competent civil court (tribunal judiciaire):
- Grasse civil court for Antibes (06).
- Nice civil court (06).
- Toulon or Draguignan civil court for the Var (83).
- Appeal before the Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal.
Legal basis: breach of contractual obligation (Art. 1231-1 Civil Code) and, where applicable, non-conformity with the VEFA contract. The judge may order:
- Forced performance (the developer pays a company directly to carry out the works, under court supervision).
- An order to reimburse the works cost as damages.
- Late-payment interest (statutory rate: 5% per year unless a higher contractual rate applies).
- Legal costs and lawyer’s fees (if a costs clause applies).
Expected ruling timeframe: 12 to 24 months depending on the court within the PACA region.
Scenario 4: Partial clearance by the developer (common pitfalls)
Many developers clear 50 to 80% of the reservations, then dig in on the « debatable » defects.
- Insufficient paint coverage: you say « 3 coats », they say « 2 is enough ». The expert measures the dry film thickness with a coating thickness gauge.
- Minor cracks: you call it serious, they call it harmless. The expert maps the cracks with a crack gauge and thermal camera.
- Facade defects: detected via thermal camera: if there’s a thermal bridge, there’s water ingress.
In these cases, insist on a joint inspection: the Cassini expert, an expert appointed by the developer, and a neutral third party (often a court-appointed expert) walk through the property together. A joint report breaks the deadlock.
How Cassini Expertise resolves the standoff
Cassini Expertise intervenes in 4 phases:
Phase 1: Expert site visit with a record of remaining reservations
The expert arrives with their own instruments:
- Coating thickness gauge: checks paint thickness and coating adhesion.
- Crack gauge: measures the width, depth and progression of cracks (alert if > 0.5 mm on a facade).
- Infrared thermal camera: detects thermal bridges, air leaks and hidden damp zones.
- Hygrometer: measures relative humidity (alert if > 60% in a dry area).
- Anemometer: quantifies unwanted air draughts (windows, seals).
- Laser level: checks partition plumb and floor flatness (DTU standard: ±3 mm/2 m).
- Inclinometer: measures terrace slopes and levelling discrepancies.
Every defect is photographed, dated and geolocated. No guesswork.
Phase 2: Detailed itemised cost estimate
The expert draws up a remediation quote:
- Paint: m² × price/m² = exact amount.
- Crack repair: number × crack type × repair technique (injection, levelling compound, etc.).
- Joinery replacement/repair: item × 2024 market rate.
- Cleaning/waterproofing: m² or linear metre × price.
- Overheads and margin: +10 to 15% (standard third-party execution rates).
Total: a document you can turn into a contract, to attach to your formal notice or court summons.
Phase 3: Expert report served on the developer
The Cassini report is a formal procedural document. You send it by registered letter to the developer along with the formal notice. They know a judge will accept this costing: it’s rare for a developer to keep stalling after that. Most act within 30 days.
Phase 4: Follow-up and final validation
Once the developer (or you) has the work carried out, Cassini returns to validate the clearance and sign the reservation-clearance statement. Only this document unlocks your balance at the bank.
The 4 questions VEFA buyers ask most
1. Can I unlock my balance without the developer clearing the reservations?
No. The VEFA agreement and Article L. 262-2 of the French Monetary and Financial Code require the notary to hold 5% until handover, then a further 5% until reservations are fully cleared. If a single reservation remains open, the bank is legally bound to withhold payment. No notary will bypass this rule: they would be civilly and criminally liable.
2. What is the legal deadline for the developer to clear reservations?
The law sets no explicit deadline. Case law generally allows 3 to 6 months after handover as a reasonable period. Beyond 12 months, this is classed as « abnormally late performance » and grounds a liability claim (damages for delay). Cassini recommends acting from month 6 if nothing has moved.
3. If I have the work done myself, do I need to keep every invoice?
Yes, and it’s essential. Keep:
- Initial quotes (2-3, as proof of market rates).
- Detailed, paid invoices (bank transfer, cheque, card: proof of payment).
- Completion certificates, site reports, before/after photos.
- Final Cassini clearance report.
This file is what will justify your reimbursement claim in court. No proof, no award.
4. Do I need a lawyer, or is an expert enough?
An expert is enough for phases 1-3 (documented formal notice). If the developer takes legal action or there’s a dispute, you’ll need a lawyer for court proceedings (Article 411-2 of the Code of Civil Procedure: legal representation is mandatory before the tribunal judiciaire, with limited exceptions). The Cassini expert works alongside the lawyer: providing the technical evidence while the lawyer handles legal strategy.
Expected costs and timeframes
Cassini expert assessment: €800 to €1,500 (visit + report + costing). Timeframe: 5 to 10 days.
Formal notice by registered letter: €100 to €300 (lawyer or bailiff). Timeframe: 5 days.
Expected outcome: 70% of cases are resolved within 30 days of the formal notice plus expert report. No court costs, balance released.
Unresolved cases: court summons = 12 to 24 months of proceedings, court and lawyer’s fees (€1,500 to €3,000), developer ordered to reimburse costs plus interest.
Based in Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur? Contact Cassini Expertise now
Cassini Expertise covers Antibes (06), Cannes, Grasse, Saint-Raphaël, Draguignan, Toulon (83) and the whole PACA region. Independent building expert with 15 years’ experience, specialising in VEFA and handover disputes. Our own calibrated instruments: coating thickness gauge, crack gauge, thermal camera, hygrometer, anemometer, laser level, inclinometer.
Phone: 04 22 46 06 04
Free initial phone consultation. Expert report within 10 working days. Independence guaranteed: we never work for developers or for structural warranty insurers.
Related reading
Cassini Expertise
Expert du bâtiment indépendant — Antibes (06·83·13·40)
📅 Mis à jour le 25/09/2026 — Cassini Expertise, expert bâtiment indépendant (06·83·13·40).