Available, Reply within 24h · Antibes · 06 · 83 · 13
04 22 46 06 04

Services

Case Study: Structural Cracks After Buying a Villa – Were They There Before the Sale?

The essentials. Detached villa bought about fifteen months earlier, with through-cracks up to 7 mm, a sunken floor slab and a roof purlin that had come away from its support by 6 to 7 mm. Are the defects structural, where do they come from, were they there before the sale, are they still moving? Visit with the buyer and a bailiff (commissaire de justice) present, crack widths measured with a rule. Technical conclusion: active differential settlement of the east corner; serious defects, pre-dating the sale and still moving; earlier surface repairs had not treated the cause.

Key data

Scope Amicable technical survey for the buyer: nature, cause, seriousness, age and progression of the defects
Property Detached villa, partial first floor, traditional rendered masonry, timber roof structure with purlins, built in the 1980s, bought about fifteen months before the visit
Location Valcastel (fictitious town, hinterland): the real place is deliberately replaced
Operations Visit with the buyer and a bailiff present (seller not summoned) · non-destructive visual inspection · crack widths measured with a rule · no probing, sampling or testing at this stage
Instruments Rule (crack widths); time-stamped photographs by the bailiff (109 photographs, 60-page record); public databases (hazards, geology, elevation, climate)
Measurement conditions One visit of about 1 hour (2.10 pm to 3.15 pm), house occupied by the buyer; weather on the day not recorded in the report; yellow storm alert the day before
Findings 11 of 11 zones visited affected · 9 show signs of earlier repair according to the report · openings up to 7 mm
Cause retained Differential settlement of the east corner: uneven bearing ground, pockets of clayey weathering over limestone, sensitive to moisture changes
Deliverable Report of 54 pages; further investigations and the principle of the repairs defined

The context

After moving in, the buyer finds cracks they consider abnormal: gaping cracks on the facade, stair-step cracks, a cracked entrance slab, ceilings and tiling affected. A bailiff draws up a 60-page record with 109 time-stamped photographs. We then step in to assist the buyer, relying on that record.

The question posed

  • Are the defects structural or superficial?
  • What is their cause?
  • How serious are they?
  • Did they exist before the sale? Are they still moving?
  • Which further investigations, and what principle of repair?

Method and instruments

The work is a non-destructive visual inspection, completed by measuring crack widths with a rule, taken with the buyer and the bailiff present. We carried out no probing, sampling or testing; the report contains no levelling or moisture-content measurement. Only the bailiff’s photographs appear in it, for admissibility reasons.

The visit lasted about an hour, in an occupied house. We went through eleven zones, in the order of the record, then consulted public databases (shrink-swell, natural disasters, elevation, drainage, geology, climate). The documents supplied were limited to the record and the buyer’s statement of the purchase date; the others were requested.

Readings

Openings measured with a rule

Zone Measurement Instrument and timing Interpretation
East facade, lintel of the east bedroom french window (facade side) about 7 mm Rule, day of the visit Through-crack, render patched along its line
Same crack, interior side about 7 mm Rule, day of the visit Same opening on both sides of the wall; plaster strip cracked
East bedroom, at the door about 3 mm Rule, day of the visit Oblique crack, thickened coating (earlier filling)
Stone paving in front of the entrance about 7 mm Rule, day of the visit Earlier cement patch, reopened
Attic room under the rafters, purlin support 6 to 7 mm Rule, day of the visit Gap between masonry and purlin, beyond an earlier metal strengthening
East bedroom, interior crack: occupant’s handwritten mark « 1 cm » Drawn on the wall a week before the visit Shows that monitoring had begun; an uninstrumented indication, larger than the rule reading, which does not allow a conclusion on progression

Environmental data

Item Value Reading
Ground elevation 222.6 m NGF (public elevation database) Flat at the top of a slope
Head of the intermittent valley 150 m to the east, at 219.6 m No clear outlet: water partly infiltrates on site
Clay shrink-swell High exposure (code 3) Weathering pockets at the top of the limestone, no thick clay layer
Droughts recognised as natural disasters 3 episodes (2007, 2022, spring 2023), all before the sale Reference episodes for dating the cracking
Seismicity, radon Zone 3 (moderate); zone 1 (low) No widespread X-shaped cracking
Average annual rainfall about 920 mm a year Dry season alternating with autumn and winter rain
Recent rainfall totals (grid point, compilation to be confirmed) 52% of normal over 3 months, 38% over 6 months, 85% over 12 months Locally severe dry season, not without precedent: 2017 (475 mm), 2022 (600 mm) and 2023 (635 mm) were drier than average

Reasoning

From cause to defects

The bedrock is a flint-bearing limestone, gently dipping (about 10°), fissured and prone to karst, whose irregular top carries clayey-siliceous weathering pockets separated by rock outcrops. Shallow foundations (not visible, to be confirmed by probing) then rest partly on rock and partly on water-sensitive weathered material: the typical configuration for differential settlement. On this flat at the head of a valley, rainwater from the pergola and the east terrace collects at the foot of the facade: saturation in winter, drying in summer.

The east corner sinks more than the rest. The walls tied to it break at the lintels, where the resisting section is smallest. The crack follows the masonry joints, hence the stair-step pattern, repeated in rooms far from one another. The south facade rotates (horizontal crack at its foot), the upper-floor load-bearing wall tilts outwards (6 to 7 mm gap at the purlin support), and ceilings and partitions follow through load transfer.

What the measurements and observations establish

  • The largest openings (about 7 mm) all lie on one axis: east facade, terrace paving, entrance paving, arcade pier. Openings in the west are smaller, consistent with settlement centred on the east corner.
  • The terrace paving crack continues the facade crack exactly: the bearing ground moves under the whole, wall and paving.

Hypotheses examined and set aside

  • Plain shrinkage of render or materials: ruled out by 7 mm openings and through-cracks, identical on the facade and interior sides.
  • Isolated roof-structure defect: the purlin gap is a consequence of wall movement, not its cause.
  • Earthquake: no recent event reported and no widespread X-shaped cracking.
  • Local cause (impact, faulty tile laying): ruled out by the stair-step pattern repeating in several rooms and in the wall tiling.
  • Recent, exceptional weather event: ruled out, as the hottest summer on record in France (anomaly of +3.6 °C) follows a series of dry years, and both the openings and the repairs covering them pre-date it.
  • Karst ground loss or cavity: not ruled out. The concentration of defects at one corner and their cyclic nature favour the moisture mechanism, but only probing can settle it.

Age relative to the sale

The sale took place about fifteen months before the visit, after the three recognised drought episodes. The buyer states that no works were carried out. Several independent material clues show that the condition recorded cannot have formed in under a year:

  • a 7 mm opening exceeds what a single seasonal cycle can produce: it takes several successive summers of shrinkage;
  • the plaster strip was applied over an already open crack, dried, was painted, then cracked again: that does not fit in one season;
  • the render repairs have weathered differently from the original, a sign of at least several months of exposure;
  • the cement patch in the paving has itself reopened by 7 mm: movement resumed after a repair that had had time to harden;
  • the metal plate strengthening the purlin was fitted to contain a gap already present, which the current gap has exceeded.

A shrink-swell crack opens at the end of summer, closes partly in autumn and winter, then opens a little more the next summer: each cycle adds a few tenths of a millimetre to a millimetre, and the residual opening accumulates. At least two generations of defects can be read: cracking repaired at surface level before the buyer moved in, then renewed movement that went through the repairs. The two summers since the sale reopened and widened cracks that already existed. The report treats the droughts of 2022 and spring 2023 as the most likely episodes behind the first generation.

Seriousness and progression

Through-cracks of 7 mm in a load-bearing wall, a sunken slab and a roof support that has come away affect the structure and the weathertightness of the envelope. The movement is active: plaster strips cracked, cracks reopened under the repairs. Without treatment of the cause, the openings will keep changing with the seasons.

Further investigations and recommended repairs

Investigation Purpose
Geotechnical study (G5 mission) Probing at the east and south facades: level of the top of the limestone, thickness of the weathered layer, identification tests (Atterberg limits, methylene blue value), search for voids, depth and width of footings, seasonal water profile
Crack tell-tales and gauges Monitoring of the 5 main cracks over 6 to 12 months, in the dry and the wet season; the west zone is to be fitted to check that it is not moving independently
Pipework checks Watertightness of buried networks and of rainwater drainage from the pergola and terrace (camera inspection)
Topographic survey and vegetation Slope of the plot, fill, distance and species of trees near the facades, water paths towards the valley
Levelling of the lower floor Measuring the slope of the ground floor to quantify the settlement
Documents to collect Sale deed, attached risk statement, diagnostics, building permit, natural-disaster orders, seller’s invoices and photos, advertisement

Repair means stabilising the foundations of the east part, controlling water inputs, then restoring structure and finishes. It will be priced on contractors’ quotes, after the geotechnical study.

Limits of the analysis

  • The inspection is visual and non-destructive: the foundations are not visible, and their type and depth are assumed. The mechanism retained is the most likely, not a proven one. The report replaces neither a geotechnical study nor project management.
  • The seller was not summoned (a point the report marks as to be confirmed): the report is not adversarial as regards the seller.
  • The purchase date and the absence of works by the buyer rest on the buyer’s statement, to be confirmed by the sale deed. Age is established by relative clues (repairs, weathering, sequence of repairs), without absolute dating of the cracks.
  • Only one set of rule readings exists: no rate of progression can be quantified, hence the recommended monitoring.
  • The rainfall totals are a compilation to be confirmed against the nearest weather station. The number of zones with earlier repair (nine in the report’s summary) should be checked against its detailed table, which shows eight with an explicit repair.
  • Not all the requested documents were available; the conclusions on the mechanism may be refined once they are read and by the geotechnical study.

Conclusions

On the technical side, the villa suffers from active differential settlement of the east corner. The defects are structural, serious, pre-date the sale and are still moving; the earlier repairs are surface treatments that did not address the cause. Our assignment, limited to the technical diagnosis, ends with delivery of the report.

What this case illustrates

A crack can be dated: repairs, materials and seasonal cycles tell its story. A report that separates technical facts from the legal debate (seriousness, age, progression) gives the buyer and their lawyer a solid base; the legal consequences are a matter for your lawyer.

See also: Staircase cracks before a sale: recent or old? · Ten-year warranty and clay shrink-swell cracks

Does your situation look like this case?

Every case is different. Describe yours: an independent building expert replies within 24 hours, with no obligation. A first consultation by video call is available.

Discuss my situation Video consultation

Town, names, addresses, references and dates removed or changed; photos not reproduced. Provided for illustrative purposes only; not advice for your own situation.

Last updated 14/11/2026 - Cassini Expertise, independent building expert, departments 06, 83 and 13.

Call First expert opinion: €45