A house perched above Vallauris, a private track called « la Rampe », and two neighbouring households who have been arguing for years over the same question: how many metres wide must the track be? The case, now pending before the Aix-en-Provence court of appeal, illustrates every classic pitfall of rights of way in our hillside towns. Here is how it works, anonymised.
The starting point: a century-old title
The house rests on a right of way created a long time ago – a very long time ago. The judge who fixed its course sat at the beginning of the 20th century in the civil court of Nice. The later deeds (partition, sale, a recently published certificate) all say the same thing: a passage about two metres wide. The neighbour, for their part, puts forward a width of 3.50 metres, based on local custom and recent planning documents.
Two metres or three and a half: the battle of the documents
The expert assignment consisted of going back through the whole documentary chain: notarial deeds published in the land registry, mid-20th-century survey plans, the old judgment, a geotechnical report, and a 79-page court-ordered expert report. Each document was cross-checked against the ground: where the track really runs, where the walls are, which structures were built along its edge and with what permissions.
Second front: the building permit obtained by the other side. The full file was consulted at the town hall – opinion of the fire service (SDIS), opinion of the Architecte des Bâtiments de France, rules of the local urban plan (PLU) and of the risk prevention plan. A remarkable result: neither the PLU nor the wildfire risk plan (PPRIF) sets a minimum width for an existing access. The argument of a « regulatory 3.50 metres » collapses on the documents.
What this case teaches
- A right of way is read first in the title deeds, not in habits or wishes: the chain of deeds prevails;
- Planning documents confirm or destroy the other side’s arguments – an SDIS opinion « not applicable » or the absence of a width rule in the PLU can be checked at the town hall, on file;
- The ground must confirm the paper: walls, structures, works declarations, records – everything is cross-checked;
- On appeal, the expert report is the backbone of the submissions: it directly feeds the lawyer’s pleading.
In this case, the expert work and the advocacy work together: the technical report checks each opposing argument, and the lawyer turns the conclusions into arguments before the court. That pairing is what makes the difference between a defence that is endured and one that is built.
A right-of-way dispute with your neighbour?
Before pleading, you need to measure, read the title deeds and check the authorisations. Our firm works across the département – Vallauris, Golfe-Juan, Antibes, Cannes, Grasse – and in court proceedings. Free quote, written conclusions within 48 hours of the visit: call +33 4 22 46 06 04 or contact us.
Survey carried out by Frédéric Faucouneau, independent building expert, Antibes, Alpes-Maritimes (06), Var (83), Bouches-du-Rhône (13). Last updated: 14 November 2026. Find out more
Last updated 14/11/2026 - Cassini Expertise, independent building expert, departments 06, 83 and 13.