The essentials. A flat of about 84 m² on the fourth floor, renovated by a general contractor for owners who live abroad. Close to €86,000 paid, a balance of about €17,000 claimed by the contractor and disputed in full, unfinished works and widespread defects, no acceptance. The contractor, duly summoned, did not attend the meeting; the expert appointed by its insurer did. The findings are visual, with no instrumented measurement: paint quantities, areas and the gaps with the insurer’s position are set out in the readings tables. Report written in French and English for the owners and their lawyer.
The context
Owners who live abroad entrust the full renovation of their flat to a general contractor (initial quote of about €80,000 incl. VAT). It works on site from mid-May to early September 2025. The site stops in August (contractor’s holiday), restarts in early September, then the contractor leaves and declares the works finished (message reproduced by the owners, original not supplied). The contractor claims a balance of about €17,000, disputed in full; the owners claim about €12,000 after a formal notice and termination of the contract in early 2026. No acceptance has been given.
The question posed
The owners, assisted by their lawyer, needed a dated, adversarial technical record: which defects, which causes, which repairs? What should they reply to the contractor’s insurer, which accepts the cause but plays down the extent?
Method and instruments
We summoned the contractor by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt, then held a joint site meeting from 9:25 to 11:28, with a bailiff and the expert appointed by the insurer present. The contractor and its lawyer, although informed, did not come (statement recorded in the bailiff’s record).
Visual, non-destructive report. No measuring instrument was used and no probing was done. The readings rely on the bailiff’s record (52 pages), our 17 photographs and the documents supplied by the owners. The areas used are those in the quotes, to be checked on site. The parties’ statements are reported as such.
Air conditioning and electrics are not in the bailiff’s record: they rest on our own observations and photographs alone, with no opening up or testing. We also examined the paint manufacturer’s written opinion and the nine damage sheets from the insurer’s expert, received about two weeks after the meeting.
Readings
Paintwork and parquet
| Area | Reading | Value | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Walls, all rooms | Painted area | About 194 m² | Reference area in the schedule of works |
| Walls | Tins used, coverage stated by the manufacturer | 5 one-gallon tins; 5 gallons cover about 100 m² in two coats | Three full coats, claimed by the contractor, physically impossible |
| Ceilings | Area | About 84 m² | Reference area in the schedule of works |
| Parquet, living room | Area | 19 m² | Included for evenness of colour and gloss |
| Parquet, bedroom 1 | Area; unvarnished patch; poorly covered strip | 16 m²; about 30 cm²; about 30 cm × 5 cm | Whitish haze, hair and brush bristles in the varnish |
| Parquet, bedroom 2 | Area; gap between two boards | 19 m²; 5 mm | Gap not filled before varnishing; bubbles, debris included |
| Parquet, total to redo | Area | 54 m² | Sanding back to bare wood, three coats of varnish |
Shower, air conditioning, glazing
| Area | Reading | Value | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hall shower | Flexible perimeter joint between floor and wall tiles | Absent (minimum 5 mm required) | Finding shared with the insurer’s expert; slope and waterproofing under the tiles cannot be checked without probing |
| Air conditioning | Heat exchanger fins, rear face | Crushed and bent in several places | Handling or installation damage on new equipment |
| Distribution board | Rows of breakers; air conditioning protection | 3 rows; C20 breaker, shared with kitchen appliances and water heater | Front face only; certificates not supplied |
| French window, main bedroom | Glass, right-hand leaf | Intact until the end of August 2025; found broken in early September (about twelve days apart) | Dated photographs and a message reporting it the day it was found |
Extents: the record and the insurer’s position
| Item | Bailiff’s record and report | Extent accepted by the insurer |
|---|---|---|
| Walls | Defects in all rooms (about 194 m²) | About 150 m² (nearly all painted walls); runs over about 0.20 m² |
| Woodwork and joinery | Frames and French windows throughout the flat | About 0.20 m² per element; about 1 m² in total for external joinery |
| Parquet | Haze, hair, bristles, debris, unvarnished patch, 5 mm gap | Stains over about 3.50 m² and bubbling over 0.50 m² |
| Ceilings | Finish defects, colour differences, ridges (living room, kitchen, bedrooms) | Roller marks over about 1.5 m² in total |
Technical and regulatory references
- DTU 59.1 (painting works): requires surface preparation and coats in line with the manufacturer’s instructions; the report ties colour variations, runs, ridges and poor opacity to it.
- DTU 51.1 (cited by the report for the parquet): dust removal and filling of gaps come before varnishing; their absence explains the inclusions and bubbles.
- DTU 52.2: requires, around tiled areas, a movement joint of at least 5 mm filled with flexible sealant and, in wet rooms, a waterproofing system under the tiles turned up at the foot of the walls.
- NF C 15-100: dedicated circuit, breaker rating, residual-current protection, load distribution; none can be assessed from the front face of the board alone.
- Article 1226 of the Civil Code: basis for the unilateral termination of the contract, notified by formal notice in early 2026.
Reasoning
Paintwork: cause, mechanism, consequence
Cause: poorly prepared substrates and paint applied in coats that were too thin or uneven. Mechanism: poor opacity and colour variations, ridges and hollows on substrates not made good. Consequence: defects on every surface, hence a full redo (sanding, primer, two finishing coats).
Hypotheses set aside. (1) Product defect: the manufacturer’s written opinion rules it out, and the supplier received neither a request for help nor a complaint from the contractor. (2) Simple end-of-job touch-ups: the defects affect every surface and two distinct paint systems (walls and frames), and the insurer itself accepts about 150 m² of walls, nearly all the painted walls. (3) Three full coats: five tins for about 194 m² of walls, when the supplier states that they cover about 100 m² in two coats.
Parquet
Inclusions, bubbles, haze and uncovered areas point to insufficient dust removal, application in unsuitable conditions and no filling of the 5 mm gap. These defects, embedded in the film, are corrected neither by an extra coat nor by local repair (3.50 m² and 0.50 m² according to the insurer): hence sanding back to bare wood.
Hall shower
Tiles laid butt-jointed against the wall tiles, with no flexible joint, undergo differential movement with the walls: the cement grout cracks, water gets under the tiles, with a risk of debonding and of water damage to the flat below. The joint cannot be created without removing the tiles. Hypothesis set aside: the insurer points to the absence of visible leaks; after a year without the shower being used, that absence does not prove waterproofing, and the defect is latent.
Air conditioning and electrics
Crushed fins on a new unit point to handling or installation damage; they reduce heat exchange. We do not conclude on the conformity of the connection: only the front face of the board was seen. The owners saw an old duct connected to the new network before the shower-room ceiling was closed, with no proof of replacement: opening it up remains necessary.
Glazing
Dated photographs from late July and from late August show the glass intact; three photographs from early September show it broken, with tile cutting on the adjoining balcony: pre-existing damage is ruled out. The contractor was the only one working on site and no longer disputes that it should bear the cost.
Acceptance and ten-year liability
No acceptance, express or tacit: the owners refused it in front of the bailiff. The insurer accepts the cause of each defect examined but classes them as cosmetic, hence in its view not covered by the ten-year warranty. Without acceptance, the ten-year warranty has not started to run: the defects fall under the contractor’s contractual liability, and the broken glass under its civil liability. Only the shower defect could affect fitness for use once in service.
According to the contractor, the owners refused access to the site. The documents do not bear this out: the contractor left the site in early September 2025 and, according to the messages reproduced by the owners (originals requested), made any intervention conditional on payment of 95% of the contract. The owners’ refusal to let it return dates from early 2026, after termination of the contract. The insurer’s sheets ignore the air conditioning, the electrics, the supplied items and the unfinished works.
Recommendations
- Obtain quotes from qualified contractors in each trade to price the remedial works: the report contains no pricing.
- Reply to the insurer with the report, the bailiff’s record and the dated photographs, and ask for the claim to be handled under civil liability as well as the ten-year warranty; declare the broken glass to the home insurer.
- Do not start repairs before the insurer agrees or a court-ordered expert report is obtained, apart from protective measures (protect the French window, switch off the air conditioning until the electrics are checked).
- Open the shower-room ceiling to check that the old ducts were replaced before it is closed for good.
Limits of the analysis
- Visual findings: the slope and waterproofing under the shower tiles, the inside of the board and the air-conditioning circuit were not checked.
- The bailiff’s records from late 2025 and the contractor’s detailed quotes and invoices were not supplied to us, nor were the originals of some of the contractor’s messages; the amounts are those in the documents, unaudited. The report may be completed when they are received.
- We are independent of the parties, their lawyers and their insurers, and we do not give a legal characterisation of the facts (a matter for lawyers, insurers or the court).
- Recommended investigations: inspection of the installation by a qualified electrician with a written report, manufacturer’s diagnosis of the outdoor unit, probing under the shower, opening of the shower-room ceiling.
What this case illustrates
When a contractor claims the balance while nothing has been accepted and defects remain, a dated, quantified, adversarial record changes the discussion: it allows a point-by-point reply to the insurer, and summoning by registered letter, the bailiff and the documented absence of the contractor give the owners and their lawyer a solid base.
See also: Handover inspection: avoiding implicit acceptance of defects · Construction defects and ten-year liability
Does your situation look like this case?
Every case is different. Describe yours: an independent building expert replies within 24 hours, with no obligation. A first consultation by video call is available.
Town, names, addresses, references and dates removed or changed; photos not reproduced. Provided for illustrative purposes only; not advice for your own situation.
Last updated 14/11/2026 - Cassini Expertise, independent building expert, departments 06, 83 and 13.