# Case Study: Buying a Second Home – Comparing Two Properties Before Signing

> Two properties, one purchase: structure, damp, security, comfort, recent works. A real, anonymised comparative pre-purchase survey.

- URL : https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/second-home-pre-purchase-survey-comparing-two-properties-case-study/
- Langue : en-US
- Mis à jour : 2026-11-14
- Site : Cassini Expertise (https://cassini-expertise.fr/)

By Cassini Expertise – Independent building expert · Menton, Nice, Antibes, Cannes, Toulon · [+33 4 22 46 06 04](tel:+33422460604)

**The essentials.** Foreign buyers are torn between two second homes on the French Riviera: a renovated three-room flat on a harbour square, and a duplex in an old-town house. The survey compares both from the purchaser’s standpoint: structure, damp, ventilation, security, comfort, recent works and works to anticipate. Provisional result, drawn from a report still at working-draft stage: moderate, correctable risk on one side; high risk with recurring defects on the other. The deciding point for the duplex: a diagonal differential-settlement crack.

Key data

| Scope | Comparative pre-purchase survey of two properties: structure, damp, ventilation, security, comfort, recent works and works to anticipate. Neither a valuation nor a regulatory compliance audit |
| --- | --- |
| Properties | A flat of 64.37 m² (certified private area), renovated in 2025, on a very busy harbour square · a duplex of 106.61 m² (certified private area) with about 78 m² of terraces, in an old-town house from the 1900s, recently renovated |
| Location | Saint-Aurel (fictitious town): the real place is deliberately replaced |
| Method | Visual, non-destructive inspection · extract airflow with an anemometer · shower trays checked for level · reading of diagnostics and invoices |
| Instruments | Anemometer · spirit level · ball-probe moisture meter (duplex) · camera and video |
| Measurement conditions | Visits in October and November 2026; duplex readings in late October 2026. No weather, number of points or occupancy stated |
| Documents | Sellers’ diagnostics (2024 for the duplex, 2025 for the flat), quotes and invoices for joinery and metalwork, window data sheet, 27 photos and 25 videos of the flat, 40 photos of the duplex |
| Reservations | Report at working-draft stage, to be completed (duplex risk statement, up-to-date termite reports, moisture-meter values) |
| Deliverable | Comparative report of 11 pages, in English for the buyers |

## The context

A couple of foreign buyers is torn between two very different properties: a flat in a condominium with individual entrances, on a harbour square, and a ground-and-garden-level duplex in an old-town house. Both were recently renovated. We assist the buyers in comparing them with full knowledge and, where relevant, in negotiating the price or the sellers’ commitments.

## The question posed

What is the condition of each property, which technical risks does it carry, which works should be anticipated, and which offers the best balance of comfort, security and risk? The survey is neither a market valuation nor a regulatory compliance audit.

## Method and instruments

The survey rests on a visual, non-destructive inspection, with no destructive probing and no instrumented moisture mapping. Three instrumented checks complete the observation: an anemometer at the extract vents of both homes, a spirit level on the flat’s shower trays, and a ball-probe moisture meter on the bedroom walls and party walls of the duplex in late October 2026 (values still to be entered, according to the report). The sellers’ diagnostics were cross-checked against the observations, without our vouching for their content.

## Readings

Readings: old-town duplex

| Zone | Measurement | Value | Instrument, date | Interpretation |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Utility-closet extract vent | Air velocity | 0.00 m/s | Anemometer, late October 2026 | No airflow: extraction inoperative at this point |
| Another extract vent | Air velocity | about 1 m/s | Anemometer, late October 2026 | Weak extraction; the report concludes the system is undersized |
| Bedroom walls and party walls | Moisture content | not reported | Ball-probe moisture meter, late October 2026 | Readings taken, values to be completed; the assessment rests on visible marks |
| Buried walls | Area and thickness | 38 m², 50 cm stone | Energy diagnostic (2024) | Uninsulated stone walls, against earth on the outer side |
| Lower level, bedroom corridor | Crack | diagonal, opening still fine (width not quantified) | Visual observation, photo, late October 2026 | Structural crack from differential settlement |

Readings: flat on the harbour square

| Zone | Measurement or data | Value | Source | Interpretation |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Ceiling extract vent | Extract airflow | values judged satisfactory (not quantified in the report) | Anemometer, October or November 2026 visit | Ventilation adequate |
| Glazed entrance door | Dimensions, glazing | 2,450 × 1,400 mm; 44/2 laminated glass (about 8.8 mm) per the invoice, 8 mm per the locksmith’s e-mail | 2025 invoice, written confirmation of early November 2026 | Delays a break-in without being anti-burglary glazing; no resistance class cited |
| Whole flat | Energy performance | class C, 148 kWh/m²/yr, €807 to €1,091/yr | Energy diagnostic (2025) | The diagnostic states ventilation by opening windows although a mechanical extract exists |

## The comparison

| Criterion | Flat on the harbour square | Old-town duplex |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Structure | No defect observed | Structural crack at the lower level (differential settlement); cosmetic crack upstairs on a bowed wall |
| Damp | No defect observed | Heavy damp marks on two un-lined party walls, mould, 38 m² of uninsulated buried walls (per the energy diagnostic) |
| Ventilation | Extract airflow measured and satisfactory | Undersized extract ventilation (0.00 m/s at one vent), to be replaced |
| Security | Standard-grade glazed entrance door onto a public square, accessible terraces, standard windows | To be checked |
| Comfort | No insulation between the two levels; noise from the square (café terraces, market, cruise passengers) | Metal windows without thermal break; uninsulated walls |
| Diagnostics | Energy class C; asbestos, lead, electrical: no issue; termite and risk reports to be renewed | Energy class C; asbestos, lead, electrical: no issue; termite report expired, risk statement missing |
| Recent works | Joinery, shutters, doors, railings, entrance door, bathrooms, electrical: 2025, invoices supplied | Recent renovation (finishes, heat pump, partial crawl space); defects persist despite the works; sellers verbally promise to line the damp walls and replace the ventilation |
| Risk level (provisional) | **Moderate, correctable** | **High, recurring defects to be expected** |

## Reasoning

### The duplex: crack, damp, ventilation

**Crack.** At the lower level, the crack starts at a corner and runs diagonally across the wall toward the staircase, an area of concentrated load. This orientation is characteristic of differential settlement (uneven sinking of shallow foundations in heterogeneous soil, a classic defect of old buildings in the area). Hypothesis set aside: a plaster or shrinkage crack would be vertical or horizontal. The opening is still fine, but it is the orientation that defines the crack. In our experience, stitching, mesh and skim, or partial underpinning do not durably stabilize foundation movement in a party-wall situation: the crack almost systematically reopens. Upstairs, the fine vertical crack on a bowed wall is judged cosmetic, to be monitored.

**Damp.** The two party walls are not lined (no stud wall, no ventilated air gap). The buried walls are 50 cm stone, uninsulated, against earth. Part of the ground floor sits directly on the ground with no crawl space, which encourages rising damp. Observed consequence: heavy damp marks on both sides and mould.

**Ventilation.** The extract (single-flow, self-regulating per the energy diagnostic) delivers no airflow at the utility-closet vent (0.00 m/s) and remains weak at another (about 1 m/s): it is undersized. The report recommends a humidity-controlled “hygro B” extract (vents in the three shower rooms and the kitchen, air inlets in the window frames); windows without thermal break encourage winter condensation.

**The promised lining.** Lining without treating the cause hides the defect: mould develops behind it. The report combines a barrier against rising damp (injection), a ventilated air gap and stronger ventilation. The announced lining will improve comfort but is not a damp treatment.

### The flat: security first

For a second home left empty part of the year, on a very busy square, resistance to break-in is the first criterion. The documents show standard protection, with no certification: no resistance class is cited for the glazed door; the glazing differs between documents (44/2, about 8.8 mm, against 8 mm) and remains basic laminated safety glass; the two documents name two different lock models, and the seller states verbally that it is certified, with no document. The terraces are reachable without particular difficulty via an adjoining steel-sheet roof and a low wall.

**Recommendation:** before the first absence, a certified lock, reinforced laminated glazing on the door, key-locking handles or bolts on the terrace windows, an alarm with detection, and a check of the insurer’s requirements. Indicative budget: €3,000 to €6,000 depending on options.

Hypotheses set aside: faulty shower installation (flatness and fall correct with a level) and inadequate ventilation (satisfactory at the anemometer). To correct: exposed connectors without a junction box in the water-heater closet. To monitor: run-off marks at the junction between the steel-sheet roof and the terrace wall.

## Technical and regulatory references

The report cites few texts; we reproduce only those it mentions.

- **A2P certification and European RC classes**: they qualify a lock’s burglary resistance. None appears in the flat’s door documents, hence the request for a certificate or a check of the marking.
- **Window weather-tightness classes (water E750, air 4, wind C4)**: good resistance to water, air and wind, unrelated to break-in.
- **Energy performance certificate (DPE)**: class C for both properties; for the duplex, it rests on the heat pump rather than on the envelope.
- **Risk statement (ERP) and termite report** (6-month validity): to be renewed for the flat, expired or missing for the duplex. **Consuel**: certificate to be requested for the flat’s new electrical panel.

## Limits of the analysis

- The report is at working-draft stage, pending documents: the conclusions are provisional.
- The duplex moisture-meter values are not reported, the crack width is not quantified and the flat’s airflows are described without values. Measurement conditions are not stated, although wall moisture varies with the season. The report does not say whether a network leak was looked for, nor what the well under a grating photographed in the duplex courtyard shows.
- The diagnostics are the sellers’ and differ from the visit on two points: a crawl space described under the whole duplex although part rests on bare ground; ventilation by windows stated for the flat although a mechanical extract exists.
- The flat’s floor level is to be confirmed: the visit places it on the 1st and 2nd floors, the diagnostics describe a street-level entrance and living areas on the 1st floor. Condominium matters remain outside the assignment.
- Recommended further checks: complete moisture values, up-to-date termite and risk reports, A2P certificate or inspection of the lock fitted, Consuel certificate, planning declaration for the street-facing windows, contractors’ warranties, the neighbour’s consent for any deep treatment of a party wall.

## Conclusions

The two properties do not carry the same risk. The flat, renovated in 2025 with clean diagnostics, calls for targeted security and comfort corrections at a controlled cost. The duplex combines defects that stem from the building fabric itself and have survived the works. The lining and the ventilation replacement are verbal only, and the crack is the subject of no commitment: the report recommends describing the works in the sale agreement and requiring an invoice and commissioning before signing.

## What this case illustrates

Comparing two properties means setting two **risk profiles** side by side, before even discussing price. A pre-purchase survey gives buyers what they need to decide or to renegotiate: insist on written commitments rather than verbal promises.

**See also:** [Pre-purchase property inspection: do you need one?](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/pre-purchase-property-survey-nice/) · [Staircase cracks before a sale: recent or old?](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/staircase-cracks-before-sale-var-villa/)

Does your situation look like this case?

Every case is different. Describe yours: an independent building expert replies within 24 hours, with no obligation. A first consultation by video call is available.

[Discuss my situation](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en-contact/) [Video consultation](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en-terms-consultation/)

*Town, names, addresses, references and dates removed or changed; photos not reproduced. Provided for illustrative purposes only; not advice for your own situation.*

---
Source : https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/second-home-pre-purchase-survey-comparing-two-properties-case-study/
