# Case Study: New-Build Villa Bought Off-Plan (VEFA) – Non-Compliance With the Permit and Specification

> New villa sold off-plan (VEFA): deviations from the permit and the specification, and whether it can be brought into line. A real, anonymised case.

- URL : https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/new-build-villa-vefa-non-conformities-permit-case-study/
- Langue : en-US
- Mis à jour : 2026-11-14
- Site : Cassini Expertise (https://cassini-expertise.fr/)

By Cassini Expertise – Independent building expert · Menton, Nice, Antibes, Cannes, Toulon · [+33 4 22 46 06 04](tel:+33422460604)

**The essentials.** New villa bought off-plan (VEFA), delivered about four weeks after the contractual date. On site, the buyer notes a series of deviations. The question: can the villa be brought into line with the permit and the specification, under what conditions and with what risk? Answer: three deviations (pool equipment room, parking and garage access, wastewater treatment) cannot be corrected without changing the authorised project; the others can be repaired, but only by heavy works in an occupied house. The measurements support this reading: no ventilation opening on any of the four crawl space walls, two mechanical ventilation outlets out of three with zero air speed, a drain field of 50 linear metres against 60 specified.

Key data

| Scope | Review of the documents (permit, amended permit, planning rules, specification); visit, record of defects and analysis of non-compliance risks; photographic and air-speed measurements |
| --- | --- |
| Property | New villa on a plot of about 1,360 m², bought off-plan, delivered a little after the contractual deadline |
| Location | Castellaure (fictitious town): the real place is deliberately replaced |
| Operations | 3-hour visit (9 a.m. to 12 noon) with the buyer and a bailiff · measurements cited with their record numbers · no probing or opening-up of works |
| Instruments | Anemometer and manometer (not calibrated, indicative values) · spirit level · laser distance meter for the dimensions recorded in the bailiff’s report |
| Measurement conditions | Non-destructive method, amicable and non-adversarial assignment · rain the day before the visit · water pressure read under two draw-off conditions |
| Findings | Wastewater treatment and drain field, unventilated crawl space, mechanical ventilation that does not extract, pool equipment room, garage access, garage roof, balustrades, water supply |
| Analysis | Three deviations that cannot be corrected without changing the authorised project · deviations repairable by heavy works |
| Deliverable | Report of 250 pages, of which 34 pages of report and 216 pages of appendices (bailiff’s records and wastewater inspection) |

## The context

A buyer purchases a new villa off-plan (VEFA) from a build-and-sell company, which entrusted the works to a general contractor. Delivery takes place about four weeks after the contractual date. A first bailiff’s record is drawn up about six weeks after delivery, a second on the day of our visit; the seller replies by letter to the complaints. The buyer wants to know what, in what was delivered, departs from what was authorised and promised.

## The question posed

Can the villa be brought into line with the building permit (original and amended) and the contractual specification? Under what conditions, and with what risk? We assist the buyer: the report does not prejudge the contractual consequences, which are a matter for the buyer’s counsel.

## Method and instruments

We reviewed the documents (deed and descriptive notice, permit and annexed opinions, amended permit, plans « as modified », planning rules, drainage and thermal studies, ventilation and airtightness reports, the seller’s letters, the records). The visit lasted three hours. The survey is visual and non-destructive; the seller, its general contractor and its architect were not summoned.

- **Anemometer**: air speed at 3 ventilation outlets (laundry room, kitchen, water heater room), one value per outlet; not calibrated.
- **Manometer**: water pressure at 2 points (outdoor tap on the east side, upstairs shower), then a test with the irrigation running; not calibrated.
- **Spirit level**: fall of the pipe between two rainwater manholes; plumb of the glass panels of the two balustrades.
- **Laser distance meter**: distance between the fence and the facing of the north facade, and width of the shared access road (earlier record, a single point).

## Measurements

### Dimensions and deviations

| Zone | Reading | Specified or reference | Interpretation |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| North facade | 2.683 m between fence and facing | 3.00 m on the amended permit site plan | 32 cm, to be confirmed against the surveyed boundary |
| Outdoor parking space | 2.95 m wide, in front of the garage door | 3.00 x 8.00 m against the fence | Space and garage mutually exclusive |
| Garage | Lengthened by 2.05 m; facade 3.00 m from the fence | Original plan | Origin of the parking problem |
| Drain field | 4 drains of 12.5 m, i.e. 50 linear m; 14 m between distribution manhole and end manhole | 3 x 20 linear m, i.e. 60 m | 10 m missing, 17% less |
| Tree near the drain field | 8 m | More than 3 m (wastewater inspection) | Distance respected |
| Crawl space | No opening on 4 walls; 20 cm walls; 2 rusted bars | Terracotta grilles in the facade | No air renewal |
| Rainwater | No fall at the spirit level; upstream manhole wet, downstream dry after rain | Inspectable network connected to the basin | Roof water does not reach the network |
| Balustrades | Gaps of 11 and 9 cm; glass out of level in 2 planes | Fitted plumb | 11 cm: accepted limit; appearance defect |

### Air speed at the ventilation outlets

| Outlet | Measurement | Expected |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Laundry room | 0.95 m/s | Around 2 to 3 m/s (3 m/s accepted in the record) |
| Kitchen | 0 | High flow of 120 m³/h stated in the ventilation report |
| Water heater room | 0 | Continuous extraction |

### Water pressure

| Conditions | Point | Value |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Villa network alone | East outdoor tap | 2.6 bar |
| Villa network alone | Upstairs shower | 5.4 bar |
| Drip irrigation running | Upstairs shower | Less than 0.85 bar (first readable graduation, needle on zero) |

## Technical and normative references

- **Permit, art. 2, maintained by the amendment, art. 3**: pool room « completely buried and enclosed », outdoor parking space in the specified surface, wastewater system designed with the competent service. Three deviations result.
- **DTU 64.1** (non-mains wastewater): pumping station without lid seal, alarm out of order, no ventilation.
- **DTU 43.1** (flat roof waterproofing): standing water on the garage roof fatigues the waterproofing.
- **DTU 60.11** (water flows, simultaneity): PE25 pipe and pressure below 0.85 bar with simultaneous draw-off.
- **Order of 24 March 1982** (ventilation flows), **NF P01-012** (balustrades, gaps of 11 and 9 cm judged within the accepted limit), **NF C 15-100** (panel not closed, penetrations not sealed).
- **Article R 128-2 of the construction and housing code**, cited in the deed: no pool alarm observed at delivery.
- **Crawl space ventilation**: code of practice, with no DTU number cited in the report.

## Reasoning

### Crawl space

Cause: no opening on any of the four walls, seen from inside. The grilles visible on the facade are fitted without passing through the 20 cm wall; the hypothesis of blocked grilles is therefore ruled out. Mechanism: without air renewal, moisture and condensation build up; two uncut reinforcing bars are already rusted and the bottom of the electrical panel opens onto this space. Consequence: a corrosion path towards the slab, made worse by the lack of ventilation, and moisture in the technical cabinet.

### Ventilation and water

Two ventilation outlets out of three read 0, the third 0.95 m/s against 3 m/s accepted; the ventilation report supplied covered only one outlet and one of two fans, so it does not contradict these values. For water, the gap between 2.6 and 5.4 bar implies a pressure reducer or a flow during one measurement: the report leaves it to be explained. The irrigation test is clearer: the shower pressure drops below 0.85 bar, with no flow, and recovers when it stops. With a PE25 pipe, this characterises a flow deficit with simultaneous draw-off.

### Rainwater and parking

A pipe with no fall, a wet upstream manhole and a dry downstream one after rain: the water stays upstream, as the first record had already noted (standing water with larvae). As for parking, the amended permit lengthened the garage by 2.05 m, bringing its facade to 3.00 m from the fence; the only possible space is in front of the door, with a right-angle entry. Relaying the surface does not change this use.

### Complaints examined and not upheld

- Shared access road of 4.80 m: measured at a single point, whereas the fire rule calls for 5 m or another approved solution; road outside the plot.
- Distance of 3.50 m at the entrance: 3.57 m measured; the difficulty comes from the angle, not the width.
- Power of 12 kVA: the specification sets none; what remains is insufficient adaptation to the equipment delivered (cumulated loads above 30 kW).

## Analysis: what can be corrected, and what cannot

### Three deviations that cannot be corrected without changing the authorised project

- **Pool equipment room.** Two routes: build a buried room (excavation near the foundations, waterproof tanking, reworking of the pipework, several weeks of machinery on an already occupied plot), or obtain an amended permit, assessed under the revised planning rules and in a protected area with the opinion of the heritage architect, with no guarantee of success.
- **Parking and garage access.** An independent space means taking land from green areas (margin of 52 m² across the development to hold 80%), hence an amended permit subject to functional manoeuvring conditions that the delivered layout does not meet.
- **Wastewater treatment.** Putting the tank back at the approved position or adding the 10 missing linear metres of drain field requires a new design file, validation by the competent service, excavation between the house, the pool and the drain field, and an inspection before backfilling.

### The other deviations are repairable, but with heavy works in an occupied house

| Item | Works needed | What it implies |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Crawl space | Cores right through 20 cm concrete walls under render and stone facing, treatment of the reinforcement, drying, sealing of the panel | Reworking of finished facades; moisture and corrosion already under way to be monitored over time |
| Garage roof | Removal of the waterproofing, new falls, new waterproofing | Roof to be redone entirely |
| Rainwater | Excavation along the facades, relaying with a fall | Reworking of finished surroundings |
| Water supply | Replacement of the pipe from the meter | Trench through the access and the garden |

On the administrative side, the permit covers several villas: the compliance certificate is only possible once the last one and the shared works are complete, and the deed gives the seller a mandate for authorisation applications.

## Limits of the analysis

- No probing or opening-up of works: the condition of the reinforcement and the moisture in the crawl space were not measured. Anemometer and manometer not calibrated: indicative values.
- To be cross-checked if the seller disputes: an adversarial pressure and flow test with a flow meter; a surveyor’s measurement of the north facade and the tank; an acoustic measurement of the pool room; probing of the reinforcement.
- The delivery record and the as-built drawing of the wastewater system were not given to us.
- The earlier record gives balustrade gaps of 11 to 13 cm, our readings 11 and 9 cm. The report does not give a legal characterisation of the deviations.

## Conclusions and deliverable

The report lists the deviations, ties each to the document it contradicts (permit, specification or code of practice), separates what is repairable from what would need an amended permit, and sets out the further investigations to carry out. It was reissued as version 3 after the bailiff’s record was rectified, without changing the conclusions.

## What this case illustrates

In a VEFA sale, **compliance is judged on documents as much as on site**: a report that links each measurement to the permit, the specification and the binding rules lets the buyer know what is repairable, what is not, and what they can ask for.

**See also:** [Handover report reservations: legal value and deadlines](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/handover-report-reservations-cannes/) · [VEFA expert, French Riviera](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en-vefa-off-plan-expert-french-riviera/)

Does your situation look like this case?

Every case is different. Describe yours: an independent building expert replies within 24 hours, with no obligation. A first consultation by video call is available.

[Discuss my situation](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en-contact/) [Video consultation](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en-terms-consultation/)

*Town, names, addresses, references and dates removed or changed; photos not reproduced. Provided for illustrative purposes only; not advice for your own situation.*

---
Source : https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/new-build-villa-vefa-non-conformities-permit-case-study/
