# Case Study: New-Build & Renovation Workmanship Defects Survey – Castelmar, French Riviera

> A real survey conducted in English for international owners: workmanship defects across structural and finishing trades…

- URL : https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/case-studies-new-build-defects-castelmar/
- Langue : en-US
- Mis à jour : 2026-11-14
- Site : Cassini Expertise (https://cassini-expertise.fr/)

By Cassini Expertise – Independent building expert · Menton, Nice, Antibes, Cannes, Toulon · [+33 4 22 46 06 04](tel:+33422460604)

**The essentials.** Renovated villa, Castelmar area (06). Ten civil engineering and finishing defects recorded after completion of a renovation contract, three of them rated major: uneven stair riser heights (19 mm difference), damp at the base of a wall and a rainwater discharge at the foot of the façade. Non-destructive inspection conducted in English, benchmarking every defect against the French codes of practice (NF DTU). A 15-page report prepared the owners for the joint meeting with the contractor, where three points remained in disagreement and one unanswered.

Key data

| Scope | Survey of workmanship defects after completion of a renovation contract, ahead of a joint meeting with the contractor |
| --- | --- |
| Location | Castelmar (fictitious coastal town): the real place is deliberately replaced |
| Method | Visual, non-destructive inspection, element by element; spot measurements and photographs |
| Instruments | Tape measure, spirit level, surface thermometer, moisture meter, photographs (66 pictures) |
| Measurement conditions | Visit on 23 September 2026 from 3:30 pm, with the owners present; weather not recorded in the report |
| Benchmark | French codes of practice (NF DTU), associated NF and EN standards, Civil Code articles |
| Findings | Early-age cracking of a concrete ramp · uneven stair riser heights · external joinery out of plumb · damp at the base of a wall · defective paintwork and finishes |
| Deliverable | 15-page report written in English, then 7-page minutes of the joint meeting |

## The context

The property is a detached house, rendered and painted, with a tiled roof, on a terraced plot at roughly 30 to 40 m above sea level and less than 300 m from the sea. The climate is Mediterranean (heavy rain in autumn, salt spray aggressive to metals) and the municipality is in seismic zone 3. A renovation had been entrusted to a main contractor. After completion, the owners, an international couple, identified workmanship defects, which the contractor had acknowledged in writing in June 2025 before reclassifying them as a difference of opinion.

## The question posed

We assisted the owners. They needed a dated record of the defects, an assessment of each against the French codes of practice (NF DTU), and a technical basis for the joint meeting set by the contractor. We characterise the defects and put forward probable causes, without prescribing repairs.

## Method and instruments

The visit took place on 23 September 2026, from 3:30 pm, with the owners present. The inspection is visual and non-destructive: no dismantling and no probing. We used a tape measure, a spirit level (ramp gradient, plumb of the joinery), a surface thermometer and a moisture meter. The report does not state the weather, the instrument models or the number of measurement points; 66 photographs were taken, 27 of them reproduced.

Each sheet gives the finding, the analysis, the references, the action required and a severity: major, significant or minor.

## Readings

Measurements taken on 23 September 2026

| Area | Measurement and instrument | Value | Interpretation |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Main staircase, one flight | Height of four risers (tape measure) | 17.5 cm; 18.2 cm; 19.3 cm; 19.4 cm | Difference of 1.9 cm between the lowest and the highest; 19 mm against the usual tolerance of ± 5 mm, well outside tolerance, risk of falls (major) |
| Lower rooms, external-side wall | Surface temperature difference between lower and upper wall (surface thermometer) | 1 to 2 °C | Colder wall base, consistent with localised moisture |
| Lower rooms, external-side wall | Moisture meter at 30 cm above floor | 0.13 (rest of the wall dry) | Localised damp at the wall base; unit and scale not stated |
| Living-room joinery | Plumb and gap between leaf and frame (level, tape measure) | Gaps clearly different between top and bottom, not quantified | Frame installed outside tolerance |

## Technical and regulatory references

- **NF DTU 21, NF DTU 13.3, NF EN 206/CN:** execution of concrete and curing suited to the weather; absent or insufficient curing explains early-age cracking.
- **NF DTU 52.2:** adhesive-fixed tiling, regular joints of at least 2 mm for pressed tiles and 6 mm for terracotta or stone with irregular edges; in a bathroom, perimeter joints in elastomeric sealant and waterproofing under tiling in the shower.
- **NF P 01-012 and Blondel’s rule (2h + g = 60 to 64 cm):** riser height between 16 and 21 cm in a dwelling, identical over the flight to within ± 5 mm.
- **NF DTU 36.5, NF EN 14351-1:** installation of windows, checks of plumb, level and gaps, packing, continuous sealing. **NF DTU 36.2** by analogy for the two external timber units.
- **NF DTU 20.1:** damp-proof course at the wall base, tie between a new wall and existing masonry (seismic zone 3). **NF DTU 13.11 / 13.12, 65.4:** foundations and a ventilated, accessible crawl space, which a walled-up space contradicts.
- **NF DTU 59.1:** substrate preparation, prior treatment of cracks, complete system with primer; **NF DTU 42.1** where façade cracks exceed 0.2 mm.
- **NF DTU 25.41, 26.2 / 52.1, 60.1:** flatness of ceilings and substrates; corrosion-resistant materials in humid environments.
- **NF DTU 60.11, 40.5; Civil Code articles 640 and 681:** rainwater disposal at a safe distance from the foundations.
- **NF P 03-001; Civil Code articles 1792 and 1792-6:** handover and reservations; ten-year liability and one-year completion guarantee.

## Findings and reasoning

### Concrete ramp: early-age cracking

![Crack running across the external concrete slab near the villa](https://cassini-expertise.fr/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ec3-crack-slab.jpg)

*Crack in the external concrete: it appeared in fresh or very young concrete.*

![External slab crack - wider context](https://cassini-expertise.fr/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ec3-crack-slab-wide.jpg)

*Wider view: the ramp runs along a retaining wall and has no means of collecting surface water.*

The cracks appeared while the concrete was still fresh or in the very early stages of hardening. Mechanism: uncontrolled plastic or drying shrinkage (absent or insufficient curing in hot, windy or sunny weather, excess water, no contraction joints, insufficient or mispositioned reinforcement). Consequence: a placing defect, made worse by run-off flowing over the cracks and along the retaining wall. Hypotheses set aside: ageing of the structure (the cracking is early-age) and the gradient (checked with a level, judged correct). At the meeting the contractor attributed the cracks to the substrate; we maintained the finding, a crack born in fresh concrete pointing to shrinkage. Severity: significant.

### Staircase: a safety defect

Tile joints vary in width from one joint to the next and along the same joint, which reveals a setting-out defect. Uneven riser heights are more serious: over four risers, 17.5 to 19.4 cm, a 19 mm difference against a usual tolerance of ± 5 mm. The origin may be a setting-out error by the tiler (thickness of the finish not allowed for) or an uncorrected structural stair; the two hypotheses are not separated. Severity: major. The contractor offers to redo the joints and says it can do nothing about the riser heights: disagreement recorded.

### Joinery and external timber units

The living-room window and French door are out of plumb, with crooked stiles, misaligned handles, difficult closing and variable gaps. These symptoms are consistent with a frame installed outside tolerance (insufficient packing, fixings that distorted the frame). Adjusting the hardware does not correct a frame that is out of plumb: the defect returns and air- and water-tightness is no longer ensured. Severity: significant. The contractor offers to replace components and seals; we ask for a joint check of plumb after the work. The terrace cupboard and bin-store unit show the same defect (door out of plumb, irregular gaps); its repetition on two units suggests a faulty installation method. Severity: minor to significant. The contractor attributes it to weather; the defect recorded is an installation defect, independent of the paint. The contract documents must settle it.

### Bathroom

Uneven joints partly filled with sealant, poorly executed cuts, rust on the shower fittings with no apparent cause, a misaligned mirror, variable floor-to-ceiling height. Sealant does not replace a tile joint in a wet room. The rust points to non-stainless fixings or stainless steel of inadequate grade, a defect that will get worse. The mirror is misaligned because the ceiling is not level. Severity: significant. Recolouring the joints and moving the mirror, as the contractor proposes, act neither on the joints nor on ceiling flatness.

### Damp at the wall base and rainwater

In the lower entrance hall and dressing room, the base of the external-side wall is 1 to 2 °C colder and the moisture meter reads 0.13 at 30 cm above the floor, the rest of the wall being dry. The crawl space is walled up behind the stone cladding, so the foundations cannot be inspected. Three mechanisms remain possible: rising damp (absent or failed damp-proof course), water ingress at the foot of the façade, and condensation encouraged by the thermal bridge. A rainwater downpipe discharges at the foot of the façade, next to the entrance step. According to the owners it dates from about ten years ago, before the contract (to be confirmed from the documents); the 2024-2025 drainage works should nevertheless have taken it into account. The damp is unlikely to subside while this discharge remains: the two defects are very probably linked. Severity: major. The contractor expressed no position on the discharge.

### Paintwork and interior finishes

On the façades: blistering and flaking, substrate cracks not treated before repainting, a single coat apparent on the upper façade. Indoors: hairline cracks at wall-ceiling junctions and between dissimilar materials with no flexible joint, ceilings not level, old cracks not treated, no primer apparent and one coat applied where the contract provides for two. Painting over cracks without opening and filling them does not stop them. At the meeting the contractor acknowledged the living-room crack and proposed a joint; we asked for justification of a tie or mechanical connections with the existing wall, a finishing joint treating only appearance. Severity: significant on the façades, minor to significant indoors.

### Other photographs from the survey

![Gap between skirting and floor slab measured with a tape](https://cassini-expertise.fr/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ec3-gap-skirting-slab-771x1024.jpg)

*Survey photograph: gap measured with a tape (point not detailed in the report).*

![Access hatch in a masonry wall](https://cassini-expertise.fr/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ec3-hatch-masonry.jpg)

*Survey photograph: access hatch in masonry (point not detailed in the report).*

![Lock keeper close-up - finishing defect](https://cassini-expertise.fr/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ec3-lock-defect-771x1024.jpg)

*Survey photograph: lock keeper (point not detailed in the report).*

![Corroding external handrail](https://cassini-expertise.fr/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ec3-handrail-corrosion-771x1024.jpg)

*Survey photograph: external metalwork in a coastal environment.*

## The parties’ positions at the joint meeting

The meeting took place on site on 8 October 2026. Nothing was dismantled or probed. Three points remained in disagreement (ramp cracks, riser heights, bathroom joints) and one unanswered (rainwater discharge). The contractor undertook to build a drainage channel along the ramp and to provide, within two weeks, a written response, a schedule and its insurance certificates; the only certificate produced at that stage covered painting. The minutes do not amount to acceptance of the works or to lifting of reservations.

## Limits of the analysis

The report is a visual, non-destructive record with spot measurements. The causes put forward are hypotheses based on the symptoms. It prescribes no repair. Still to be completed: the survey of all risers and goings, the moisture measurement grid (announced in the report but not supplied), inspection of the crawl space and foundations, a joint check of plumb after intervention, the origin of the downpipe, and the contract content for the cupboard and bin-store. The report quantifies neither the joinery gaps nor the joint widths.

## What this case illustrates

A defect carries weight in a joint discussion when it is located, measured and set against the applicable rule: a 19 mm difference in stair risers is easier to discuss than an impression of poor work. International owners on the French Riviera also face the language barrier and the French technical framework: an independent inspection conducted and reported **in English, against the French NF DTU standards**, addresses both. See also our [VEFA and new-build expertise](https://cassini-expertise.fr/expert-vefa-cote-azur/) or contact us to discuss your situation.

**See also:** [damp converted basement – Port-Larmoure](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/damp-converted-basement-port-larmoure/) · [widespread mould in a flat – Saint-Maurel](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/widespread-mould-flat-saint-maurel/)

Does your situation look like this case?

Every case is different. Describe yours: an independent building expert replies within 24 hours, with no obligation. A first consultation by video call is available.

[Discuss my situation](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en-contact/)
 [Video consultation](https://cassini-expertise.fr/en-terms-video-consultation/)

*Names, address and sensitive data anonymised; photo metadata removed. Provided for illustrative purposes only; not advice for your own situation.*

---
Source : https://cassini-expertise.fr/en/case-studies-new-build-defects-castelmar/
